Decoded Science

  • Home
  • Headlines
  • General Science
  • Applied Science
    • Calculations
    • Economics
    • Engineering
      • Aviation
      • Civil Engineering
    • Medical Science
      • Health
      • Neuroscience
      • Oncology
      • Veterinary Science
    • Political Science
      • Polling
    • Mathematics
    • Technology
      • Artificial Intelligence
      • Computing
      • Electronics
      • Gadgets
    • Social Science
      • Cognitive Science
      • Psychology
      • Sociology
      • Anthropology
        • Linguistics
  • Physical Science
    • Archaeology
    • Astronomy
    • Chemistry
      • Materials Science
    • Geoscience
      • Climate Change
      • The Environment
      • Geology
      • Meteorology
      • Oceanography
    • Life Science
      • Biology
        • Botany
        • Zoology
          • Marine Biology
          • Entomology
          • Microbiology
        • Paleontology
        • Ecology
    • Nuclear Science
  • Theoretical Science
    • Physics
    • Math Theory
  • About Us
    • Contact Decoded Science
    • Ask the Expert
    • Meet Our Experts
    • Meet Our Sponsors:
    • Browse All Articles
    • Subscribe
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use Agreement
  • Support Decoded Science

Traffic Lights and Food Choices

January 8, 2014 by Gina Putt Leave a Comment

Share5
+1
Tweet
Share
Pin
5 Shares
Better food choices come from food positioning. Image by Alvimann.

Better food choices come from food positioning. Image by Alvimann.

Are you frustrated by food labels with tiny print? Does it annoy you when  healthy food items are hidden behind junk foods? What if identifying and locating healthy food during a busy lunch hour were easier?  Would you make better meal choices?

Dr. Anne Thorndike and colleagues from Massachusetts General Hospital and Harvard Business School set out to see if better food labeling and positioning change food choices.

Labeling: Or What Traffic Lights have to Do with Food

For the first three months of the 27 month study, researchers studied what people ate at Massachusetts General hospital’s cafeteria, a busy spot serving 2285 employees.

  • 75% of the employees were white, 10% African American, 8% Latino and 7% Asian.
  • 73% were female.
  • The average age was 43.
  • The largest percentage of employees, 58% were classified as “management/clinicians” with smaller numbers of technicians, professionals, support staff, and service workers.

After they collected the initial data, researchers labeled the all the cafeteria’s food. Items were marked with simple red, yellow, or green labels to indicate how relatively unhealthy or healthy a particular food choice might be.




The criteria for placing items in a particular category was based on the 2005 food pyramid. The researchers explain that they labelled every item “based on three positive criteria (fruit/vegetable, whole grain, and lean protein/low-fat dairy as the main ingredient) and two negative criteria(saturated fat and caloric content). Items with more positive than negative criteria were green, items with equal positive and negative criteria were yellow, and items with more negative than positive criteria were red.”

Zero calorie beverages were all labeled green.

Choice Architecture Intervention

The next step, which researchers called “choice architecture intervention,” involved making healthy items easier to find, such as  “rearranging items in the beverage and sandwich refrigerators to put all the green items at eye level; placing baskets of bottled water throughout the cafeteria;and providing prepackaged salads next to the pizza counter.

Researchers tracked purchases for another 24 months following the initial three month period.  Each day, the cafeteria sold an average of 16,834 items.

Design Strengths

The cafeteria research differed from many studies because it did not rely on self-report, but rather drew conclusions from objective sales data.  The 24 month time-span was also unique, allowing researchers to identify whether or not behavior persisted.

The Impact of Traffic Light Labeling and Choice Architecture

A traffic-light system easily identifies problem foods. Image by kconners.

A traffic-light system easily identifies problem foods. Image by kconners.

What happened? Employees changed their eating habits.  The percentage of red-labeled food that employees purchased decreased from 24% of items to 21% of items.  Purchases of green items went from 41% to 45%.

Most encouraging of all, the change was lasting – with the purchases at 24 months being somewhat healthier than at the 12 month mark.  Furthermore, all employees shared the healthy choices.  The authors write, “analyses of employee purchases by age and gender did not demonstrate any important differences.”

In an exclusive interview with Decoded Science, Dr. Thorndike admits, “when we started the project I was not sure that the changes in purchasing behavior would stick over the two years, but I am now convinced that our results demonstrate these types of labels can have lasting effects.”

Food Labeling and Healthy Choices

Dr. Thorndike summarizes the work this way, “[c]urrent food labels require literacy and numeracy skills to interpret, and they can take a lot of time to read.  Having a system that conveys some basic nutrition information quickly, whether you are at a cafeteria, the grocery store, or a restaurant, can help a larger proportion of the population make healthier food choices.”

In a world of increasingly overweight and obese people who suffer from a variety of life-style diseases, simple changes in how food is presented could make an impact on our waistlines and health-care costs.

Share5
+1
Tweet
Share
Pin
5 Shares

Filed Under: Headlines, Sociology Tagged With: cafeteria, choice achitecture, diet, food choice, food positioning, food pyramid, healthy food

Resources for this article

Thorndik, Anne, et al. Traffic-Light Labels and Choice Architecture: Promoting Healthy Food Choices. (2014). American Journal of Preventative Medicine. Accessed on January 08, 2014




Decoded Everything is a non-profit corporation, dependent on donations from readers like you. Donate now! Your support keeps the great information coming!

Donation Information

I would like to make a donation in the amount of:

$500$200$100$50$20$10$5Other
Other:

I would like this donation to automatically repeat each month

Tribute Gift

Check here to donate in honor or memory of someone
Check here if this is a memorial gift
Name of person to be honored:
Send acknowledgement via email
Send acknowledgement via postal mail
Email Name:
Email:
Name:
Address:
City:
State :
Province:
Country:
Postal Code:

Donor Information

First Name:
Last Name:
Email:
Please do not display my name publicly. I would like to remain anonymous
Add me to your mailing list

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Connect with:
Facebook

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About the Author

Gina Putt

Gina Barrett Putt holds a Master's degree in Sociology from the University of South Alabama and has taught both psychology and sociology at the college level. She possesses experience in housing, gerontology, mental health, and ... Read Full Profile

Follow Decoded Science

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
signupheredailydosedecsciv2


Science Everyone's Talking About

  • Genetically Modified Organisms: Pros and Cons of GMO Food Genetically Modified Organisms: Pros and Cons of GMO Food What are the benefits and risks of genetically modified... under Headlines, Health
  • Don't Pass Go: How a Legal Gun-Carry Permit Can Land You in Jail Don’t Pass Go: How a Legal Gun-Carry Permit Can Land You in Jail Selective prosecution and confusing laws mean criminal... under Criminology, Headlines
  • Birthdays Can Have Power, Perfection, And Abundance: Fun With Numbers Birthdays Can Have Power, Perfection, And Abundance: Fun With Numbers The numbers associated with the years in a human life s... under Headlines, Mathematics
  • Chemistry Questions: Organic Compounds, Life, and Vitalism Chemistry Questions: Organic Compounds, Life, and Vitalism Current scientific theories as to the origin of life ar... under Chemistry
  • Air Conditioning and Pressurization Systems in Modern Aircraft Air Conditioning and Pressurization Systems in Modern Aircraft For any modern aircraft to fly at high altitudes, i... under Aviation

Today's Most Popular Science Articles

  • Introducing Math Symbols for Union and Intersection Introducing Math Symbols for Union and Intersection
  • Norovirus Facts: 5 Things You Didn't Know About Stomach Flu Norovirus Facts: 5 Things You Didn’t Know About Stomach Flu
  • Which Chemical Bond is Stronger: Ionic vs. Covalent Bonds Which Chemical Bond is Stronger: Ionic vs. Covalent Bonds
  • Genetically Modified Organisms: Pros and Cons of GMO Food Genetically Modified Organisms: Pros and Cons of GMO Food
  • Cross Multiply to Solve Equations with Fractions Cross Multiply to Solve Equations with Fractions
  • Introducing the Factorial: the Exclamation Mark of Math Introducing the Factorial: the Exclamation Mark of Math
  • Stomach Flu Cramps: Is There Anything You Can Do For Norovirus Symptoms? Stomach Flu Cramps: Is There Anything You Can Do For Norovirus Symptoms?

Copyright © 2019 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

MENU
  • Home
  • Headlines
  • General Science
  • Applied Science
    • Calculations
    • Economics
    • Engineering
      • Aviation
      • Civil Engineering
    • Medical Science
      • Health
      • Neuroscience
      • Oncology
      • Veterinary Science
    • Political Science
      • Polling
    • Mathematics
    • Technology
      • Artificial Intelligence
      • Computing
      • Electronics
      • Gadgets
    • Social Science
      • Cognitive Science
      • Psychology
      • Sociology
      • Anthropology
        • Linguistics
  • Physical Science
    • Archaeology
    • Astronomy
    • Chemistry
      • Materials Science
    • Geoscience
      • Climate Change
      • The Environment
      • Geology
      • Meteorology
      • Oceanography
    • Life Science
      • Biology
        • Botany
        • Zoology
          • Marine Biology
          • Entomology
          • Microbiology
        • Paleontology
        • Ecology
    • Nuclear Science
  • Theoretical Science
    • Physics
    • Math Theory
  • About Us
    • Contact Decoded Science
    • Ask the Expert
    • Meet Our Experts
    • Meet Our Sponsors:
    • Browse All Articles
    • Subscribe
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use Agreement
  • Support Decoded Science