First Language – acquired or learned LLanir
How do children learn to speak? Behavioural theory assumes that children imitate what they hear, and thanks to continuous, positive reinforcement, children learn language through conditioning and habit formation. Behaviourist theorists such as Skinner also claim that all errors during first language acquisition are due to ‘bad habit formation,’ which, in due course, children correct as they hear and imitate accurate speech. In contrast to behaviourists, ‘nativists,’ like Chomsky, believe that human beings are born with an innate capacity for language development.
Deliberations continue between linguists regarding the importance of ‘nature’ over ‘nurture’ in acquisition of language.
Language Acquisition as a Result of Nurture
Behaviourists propose that a child’s environment is the most important factor in first language acquisition, and if a child is exposed to ‘rich language,’ then ‘good habit formation,’ and proper language development will occur. It is possible that first language acquisition includes speech imitation, but:
- Children do not imitate everything they hear; they appear to be very selective and only reproduce unassimilated language chunks. Therefore, their replications seem to be controlled by an internal language-monitoring process.
- Children learn the basic rules of language at around the age of five; the behaviourist theory cannot account for the speed that first language is acquired.
- Children say things that are not adult imitations; in particular they use inflectional overgeneralisations such as ‘goed,’ ‘putted,’ ‘mouses,’ and ‘sheeps.’
- Children produce language structures that do not exist; you often hear, “Where I am?” instead of “Where am I?”
- Children that acquire language from habit formation seem to memorize certain structures prematurely. These phrases become lodged in their minds as unassimilated chunks of information that they cannot incorporate into their own verbal expressions.
- Children produce many more sound-combinations than they hear, and understand many more than they can produce.
- Children are exposed to language performance and not to language competence. Often they are exposed to “debilitated” language, yet, they manage to extract the language rules from these utterances and speak correctly.
Click to Read Page Two: We Are Wired to Acquire Language
© Copyright 2011 Lesley Lanir, All rights Reserved. Written For: Decoded Science
thank you very much, i am doing an assignment on this topic
thnakyou i am also doing an assignment on this
this is a great article and the info is very helpful. Am currently working on an assignment to discuss how nature and nurture influence language development.
Who disagreed with skinners theory? Finding it hard to locate information ( I need 4)
However, Chomsky criticised Skinner’s theory on the basis of there being a ‘poverty of the stimulus’, suggesting there are too many complex grammatical rules for a child to learn, relying upon language input alone (Chomsky, 1976) and with that the behaviourist approach was somewhat (correctly) disregarded.
his ideology are, the ‘poverty of stimulus’ and ‘universal grammar’, the latter which “may be thought of as some system of principles, common to the species and available to each individual, prior to experience” (Chomsky, 1981, p.7).
This is a masterpiece
this article is just awesome and resourceful for students studying linguistics. Jacob, university of Zambia.
It has helped me alot in my assignment. Thanks.
interesting article. I’m presently doing an extensive research on this topic and i find your information very valuable.
thanks
The write up is good in fact it gives excellents answer to my research work from unilag nigeria. Thanks
Your article is very good indeed. Iam Linguists student at University of Bahr El Ghazal Wau, South Sudan and iam writing assignment about this issues.
Thanks a lot
an interesting article and useful for my seminar research but it lack facts and figures.
hi
thanks for your useful info in this article
i am linguistics student and i am writing a book about this issue so if you have any sources i would be more than glad to get your help
p.s.
if you don’t mind i want to use some part of your article
thanks again
Very succesful and the most clear article about language acqusation! Congratulate you!
Fatma from Turkey.
Doreen, thank you for taking the time to read my article and for your comment. Wishing you all the best with your research paper.
Best regards Lesley Lanir
I think your article is excellent. I am currently working on a research paper for school and I think your article is informative and well written.
Thanks, Doreen Vanselous